Panera Bread is known for their fresh baked breads and pastries. It has always been a good spot to stop and enjoy an assortment of cookies as well. Their old recipe for cookies was awesome, right amount of chocolate and a great texture. As of recently though they have changed the recipe for the Chocolate Chipper Cookie and not for the better.
The cookie at first glance is nothing like the old cookie. They began using bigger chocolate chunks and not as many smaller chocolate chips. The chunks are very sparse in the cookie which gives the individual more bites without chocolate than with chocolate. For how thin the cookie is there’s a chewy consistency to it and the outsides were crunchy and chewy. The cookie had the texture of a cookie that was sitting out for a while and was beginning to dry up.
Taste- 5; The taste was everything it should have been but too much dough in bites and not enough chocolate
Price- 4, $2.49; If it were the old cookie that would be worth it but for the decrease in size and overall taste it is too expensive
Texture- 3; The texture was too chewy and the outside crust was crunchy
Calories- 6, 380; For being a thin, small cookie it still has a good amount of calories but every cookie is going to have a lot of calories
Chocolate Chip Ratio- 4; Very disappointed in the Panera cookie and the chunks and flakes as they state on their website are non existent at points in the cookie
Overall Rating- 22 out of 50
Starbucks is one of my favorite places to stop for any variety of coffees but also packs an assortment of afternoon treats to satisfy any craving. One of my favorite items is the chocolate chip cookie warmed up in the oven. Any cookie is immediately elevated when it is warmed up and the chocolate is gooey.
With the first bite into the cookie the texture is the first element that is noticed. The outside has a nice crunch to it and the inside a soft, chewy bite. There are definite hints of vanilla in the cookie which is prominent in the flavor profile. When you get away from the outside of the cookie and are just eating the middle it can be too chewy and you are lost in one texture that is over powering. There is no melt in your mouth and a lot of chewing to be done to enjoy this cookie.
Taste- 6; At times while enjoying the cookie there is too much vanilla flavor and too much of a sugar flavor as well
Price- 5, $2.45; Falls right into line with Starbucks price range and about right in the middle of single cookie prices
Texture- 4; Once away from the edge of the cookie it is just too chewy and dense
Calories- 3, 570; On the higher end of calories and not as big as some other cookies that have fewer calories
Chocolate Chip Ratio- 6; On the edge where the better texture is there are not enough chips and then once in the center of the cookie there is the right amount. A more balanced throughout would really help this cookie
Overall Rating- 24 out of 50
Sprinkles is known for their gourmet cupcakes but they also over a variety of other delectable desserts. One of those is their chocolate chip cookie. I had never been to a Sprinkles before and a cupcake didn’t tempt me at all it was right to the massive cookie.
The first bite of this cookie was everything you want in a first bite. A little crunch from the outside of the cookie with a soft center. The middle can get a little heavy with the richness they pack into these cookies. The dough of the cookie is a little heavier than your typical cookie but packs a lot of different flavor profiles. Thickness wise this is one of the thicker cookies you will run into and can be too much for the individual who cannot handle the richness.
Taste- 8; This cookie was very rich and sweet but had all the right tastes of a traditional chocolate chip cookie
Price- 6; I need to get the exact price but I do remember it being a little more than most cookies
Texture- 10; The crunch of the outside with the thick softness of the inside was a perfect combination
Calories- 445, 4; Being on the smaller scale for a cookie this was very calorie rich but what do you expect with the richness
Chocolate Chip Ratio- 8; In every bite you got some chocolate chips which is exactly what you want
Overall Rating – 36 out of 50
Although it’s not a typical chocolate chip cookie it still checks off all the main ingredients needed with only one addition. The oatmeal that is in this cookie brings a little flavor but also contributes to the overall texture of the cookie. You are still tasting the main aspect of the cookie with little notes of oatmeal. The oatmeal does however weigh the cookie down and after enjoying a nice sandwich from Potbelly it is tough to finish the whole cookie. The moisture and density of the cookie is a nice element that allows for the cookie to stay soft and gives the consumer a satisfying bite each time. The crunch on the outside of the cookie also allows for a nice texture in your initial bite with a bit of softness from the center as well.
Taste– 7; Being that it does have the oatmeal in it it takes away from the traditional flavor of the cookie and for that reason it had to be downgraded
Price- $1.50, 8; Can’t really beat paying only a $1.50 for a above average sized cookie like Potbelly’s
Texture- 9; The softness mixed with the crunch of the outside is what keeps bringing you back for another bite
Calories- 420, 5; With all the goodness in this cookie it was bound to have almost a quarter of the standard persons caloric intake for a day
Chocolate Chip Ratio- 6; In my opinion there could always be more chocolate chips but this cookie does lack enough to have a couple chips in each bite
Overall Rating- 35 out of 50
Well why not? Most Americans can say they enjoy a warm, gooey chocolate chip cookie fresh from the oven. But when you don’t have the time or the baking skills to make yourself a fresh batch at home your only option is to purchase some. But where do you buy them from??
This blog is here to help with some answers to that question and give an unbiased and unfiltered opinion on restaurant, grocery store and local eateries from around the nation. Some may ask, “Why only chocolate chip cookies?”. Because chocolate chip cookies are the Grand Daddy of them all, the Rose Bowl of cookies some may say. No other cookie in my opinion is worthy of a spot on this blog or worth the wasted calories.
A little about me as well, my name is Kyle and for as long as I can remember I have loved chocolate chip cookies. When I was a little kid I remember getting three Chewy Chips Ahoy! and a glass of milk every night before bed. Which is probably what led to my chubby childhood but I grew out of that phase. But what I have never grown out of is my taste for a good chocolate chip cookie. I hope to share some of my favorite go to cookies but also find even better ones that can replace the regulars. With the good comes the bad though and I will not hold anything back because nothing will ruin your hopes of a sweet treat than a shitty cookie.
I hope as the blog grows I can get some feedback and ideas of more places to try and review. You can follow my Instagram account as well @cccookiecritic for news on new posts and anything else chocolate chip cookies!